Hive vs Nest vs Tado° - which one is right for you?
Smart energy solutions like Hive, Nest and Tado° have completely revolutionized the energy market. Now, we have the ability to control and monitor our heating from our smartphones, anywhere we like. This is incredibly convenient and user-friendly, but that’s not the only benefits energy management systems can offer.
Smart energy solutions allow for optimisation of energy performance, meaning you only use the energy you need - rather than wasting it.
The sensors contained in these systems negate the need for you to turn the heat up or down manually and they allow you to schedule your central heating (and in some cases water) remotely – giving you complete control of usage. They’ll also assess the room temperature and automatically adjust it to ensure optimum energy efficiency.
This saves you a considerable amount of money and also plays a key role in helping both individuals and businesses become more energy efficient and environmentally conscious.
With the global energy management system market valued at USD 35.17 billion in 2016 and set to hit USD 70.93 billion in 2022, now is the time to consider getting an energy management device.
In our guide below, we’ve looked at the different types of devices available to you, and the steps you can take to ensure you’re saving as much money as possible.
First things first - secure the best deal on your energy bills
To save the maximum amount of money, even before you purchase a smart energy solution, you need to ensure that you’re paying the best price for your energy.
At Love Energy Savings, we want to make sure you enjoy the biggest savings possible which all starts with helping you get the best energy tariff.
Find the best energy prices here
Choosing the right smart energy management system
With so many solutions on the market, you’ll be forgiven for feeling a bit overwhelmed when it comes to choosing the right system for you.
First of all, when you start your search, make sure that you’re looking for ‘smart energy solutions’ and not ‘smart meters’.
Smart energy solutions are operated remotely via your tablet, computer or smartphone. Whereas smart meters are an upgrade to traditional energy meters that are found in most homes and businesses - you can find more information about them in our smart meter guide.
Hive, Nest or Tado° - what’s the difference?
The three main players in the smart energy solutions game are Hive, Nest and Tado°. They each have some key differences that might play into the final decision you make. To help you decide which is the best smart heating device for your home, use our comparison table below to discover key stats of each device.
- Price £199
- Colour White
- Dimensions 8.4 x 8.4 x 3.2cm
- Weight 132g
- Languages 5
- Power 3xAAA
- Warranty 2-Years
- Sensors Temperature
- Price £199
- Colour Various
- Dimensions 10 x 10.4 x 4.8cm
- Weight 212g
- Languages 4
- Power 4xAA (Incl)
- Warranty 2-Years
- Sensors Temperature
- Price £249
- Colour Grey
- Dimensions 10.4 × 10.4 × 1.9cm
- Weight 279g
- Languages 1
- Power 2xAA
- Warranty 1-Years
- Sensors Temperature
Hive is one of the original and most well-known smart thermostats on the market. It has a variety of different features and is very user-friendly, helping it dominate the energy device market. It claims that it can save you £130 a year on heating.
Hive home automation has a range of features that can help you with more than just controlling your central heating. The device also boasts frost protection (identifying when the temperature drops below a certain level and warming the premises up so pipes don’t freeze) and has a holiday mode function.
One of the best features for tech-lovers is that when Hive is paired with the Amazon Echo, you can control your heating via voice control - welcome to the home of the future!
Hive doesn’t include a motion or light sensor - which Tado° and Nest both boast as standard. It also requires installation from an official British Gas engineer (but you don’t actually have to be a British Gas customer to use Hive)
Nest hit the market back in 2014 when Google purchased Nest Labs – a company that specialises in home automation devices. Since then, the ‘Nest vs Hive’ debate has raged on, but Google’s entry into the market has a couple of tricks up its sleeve that give it an edge
Out of the three smart energy devices we’ve compared, Nest is the most advanced in terms of sensory abilities. Not only does it monitor the room’s current temperature and adjust it accordingly, it also considers lighting, humidity and motion – intelligently recognising when you’re in the room or not. It has the capability to alert you when there’s an opportunity to save energy and can even control your hot water.
It also has a built-in holiday mode that allows you to schedule your heating so you know you’ll be coming back to a warm home (or office).
The biggest advantage of Nest over Hive or Tado° is that its smart system learns your schedule so you don’t have to programme it every day - instead, it intuitively adapts to you.
Much like the Hive thermostat, the Nest recommends professional installation, which you can either bundle in the price or arrange separately. These auxiliary costs make it the most expensive smart thermostat on the market although generally speaking, you’ll recoup the associated costs within the first two years.
Unlike the other two devices in this list, Nest requires a plug socket. This might not be a problem if you’ve been involved in your house build from the ground up but older properties might want to consider this before investing.
Finally, while the Nest thermostat will heat the room it is in perfectly, you will need multiple thermostats for other rooms. So you’ll have to buy more than one unit if you want to heat your entire property remotely. That said, you can control up to 20 thermostats at one time.
Tado° may be less well-known than Hive or Nest, but it’s equipped with a number of features that help it stand out from the crowd.
Tado° claims that it will cut your energy bills by 31%, paying for itself in only 12 months. And out of the three smart energy management systems we’ve looked at, Tado° is the only one which provides a guide for self-setup - a sign of it’s simplicity. Alternatively, you can pay £90 for a professional installation.
One reason why we’re warming to Tado° is the introduction of the Smart Radiator Thermostats. Fit one of these to each radiator in your house and you’ll have room-by-room control of your home’s entire eco-system. You can heat up or turn-down individual rooms depending on where people are in the house using the app.
Other great features include open-window detection, geolocation automation (meaning your thermostat can be configured to turn on/off automatically when your phone is within a set distance of the device), and humidity warnings, which helps reduce chances of damp.
Tado° can also link to your IFTTT, Amazon Echo or Apple HomeKit.
There have been rumours of minor software malfunctions, but regular firmware updates and bug fixes should put your mind at ease.
Which smart energy solution is best?
Each of these smart energy systems can save you money and have their own individual benefits and drawbacks. The one you choose will depend on your property and individual needs, so your decision about which is the best smart thermostat in the UK should be based on what you’re really looking for.
The best way to maximise your energy on your heating is a smart energy system combined with the best energy deal. At Love Energy Savings, we can save you up to 40% on your home and business energy. Before you invest in a smart energy system, make sure that you’re with the right energy supplier.
See how much you could save on your energy bills...
If, like us, you’ve got that Hive jingle from the radio stuck in your head, you may well be interested to know which energy management device is the best on the market right now. This guide will directly compare the top three so you can make an informed decision when it comes to smart energy management in your home, or even in your office.
Nest vs Hive vs Tado
Whether you choose to embrace smart technology or not, there is no getting away from the fact that it is going to revolutionise the way we heat our homes and businesses. Manual thermostats will soon be a thing of the past and new, intuitive systems will replace them. The sensors contained in this new generation of thermostats will not only negate the need for you to turn the heat up or down manually – allowing you to schedule your central heating (and in some cases water) remotely – but they’ll also save you money by assessing the room temperature and automatically adjusting to ensure optimum energy efficiency.
More than half of the energy we consume in the home is for central heating, so it makes sense to take advantage of the fantastic technology we have available to us. But, as with anything these days, we have a myriad of devices and brands to choose from – which can make choosing your smart thermostats a bit of a minefield.
To make things easier, the energy team here at Love Energy Savings have compared the top three devices out there to help you make an informed decision when it comes to selecting a smart energy device for your home or office.
Please note, these are NOT smart meters, but home automation systems. They are “smart” as they can be operated remotely via your tablet, computer or smartphone. To find out more about Smart Meters simply click here.
Nest hit the market back in 2014, when Google purchased Nest Labs – a company that specialises in home automation devices.
Out of the three smart energy devices we’ve compared, Nest is the most advanced in terms of sensory abilities. Not only does it sense the room’s current temperature and adjust it accordingly, it also considers lighting, humidity and motion – intelligently recognising when you’re in the room or not. It has the capability to alert you when there is an opportunity to save energy and can even control your hot water.
Going on holiday? No problem, holiday mode allows you to schedule your heating so you come back to a warm home or office. However, the biggest advantage of the Nest vs Tado or Hive is that it learns your schedule so that you never have to worry about whether you’ve programmed the device that day or not – it adapts to you and your lifestyle. The Nest certainly seems to have taken the concept of smart energy management that little bit further than the rest of the pack!
In terms of disadvantages, the Nest does highly recommend professional installation, unless you are well trained in electronic installation. It also requires a plug socket to be close by as it uses a rechargeable battery instead of your standard AA batteries. Another downside is that while the room the Nest sits in will be perfectly temperate at all times, it does only adapt to that room, leaving the rest of your house, or office to fend for itself.
On the plus side, you can now add additional devices to compliment your Nest device including a smoke detector or indoor and outdoor security cameras so not only can you rest assured that your heating will be on when you get back, but you can also rely on your house and belongings being there too.
Whether you love or hate their catchy jingle, Hive continues to be one of the best known and original smart energy management devices on the market. In terms of value, it’s claimed that it could save you £130 a year on heating, paying for itself in under two-years. You don’t have to take that as a given, because it will also show you how much money you have saved through being energy efficient too.
As the jingle says, “with Hive you can control your home, from your phone” but alongside this the device also boasts frost protection, identifying when the temperature drops below a certain level and warming the premises up so pipes don’t freeze, which works well with its holiday mode function – so you can go away knowing everything will be in working order upon your return.
Disadvantages of the Hive include a lack of motion or light sensor (which Tado° and Nest both include as standard) and it also requires professional installation by a British Gas engineer. It should be noted that you do not have to be a British Gas customer to use Hive, but it would probably help.
The latest update does have a rather nifty new feature, when paired with Amazon’s Echo, you can now control your heating via voice control so you don’t even have to get your phone out!
Of the three smart energy management systems we’ve compared, this is perhaps the lowest maintenance allowing you to easily install it yourself, without the need for a professional. There’s no user interactivity required with the Tado° system as it changes the temperature based on your daily routine and behaviour. This device is more of a personal heating assistant for the home or office, as it works out where you are in the building and sets the heat, based on your phone’s location.
It’s claimed that the Tado° will pay for itself in 12 months, cutting your energy bills by an average of 31%. Weather forecast integration also means that the Tado° system is smart enough to adapt indoor temperatures to outdoor conditions, it’s also able to sense humidity.
For those of you who aren’t sure whether or not to invest in a smart energy management system, Tado° gives consumers the opportunity to rent the system for £6.99 a month so you can trial it. On the other hand, if you’re a connoisseur of smart technology, Tado° is equally appealing, capable of linking to your IFTTT , Amazon Echo or Apple HomeKit.
Beyond hearsay of minor software malfunctions, there’s very little wrong with this lesser known option and given that it’s cheaper than the Hive and easier to install than the Nest, Tado° is a very appealing option.
Nest vs Hive vs Tado: Which is the best?
All three of the smart energy systems we’ve reviewed here have their own benefits and drawbacks, but after careful consideration we believe that Tado° is slightly ahead of the pack when looking at the devices overall. However, if you require a device leading the way in technology, Nest would be a preferable choice. As for Hive, well, it’s the old reliable favourite, professionally installed and with numerous add-ons available – which isn’t exactly a bad choice!
So, there you have it, the Love Energy Savings Guide to Smart Energy Solutions. As you can see, there are some seriously nifty pieces of kit on the market at present if you decide that smart energy management is the way forward for your home or business. As always, we’re completely impartial and can see the benefits of all of these thermostats but ultimately, the quickest and easiest way to save money on your energy is to ensure that you’re on a cheaper business energy tariff.
While these smart energy management systems can save you around a third on your bills, here at Love Energy Savings, we can save you 40%, with no need to invest in any device or installation services.
If you’d like to find out how much you could save simply click the button below to compare the prices available now!